Wondering if ‘All the Light We Cannot See’ is a good watch? Let’s dive into what makes this story tick and whether it’s worth your screen time.
Is ‘All the Light We Cannot See’ good? This is a question many fans of the novel and newcomers alike are asking with its recent adaptation into a Netflix series.
Quick Answer: It Depends
Whether ‘All the Light We Cannot See’ is good depends on what you’re looking for. If you’re a fan of the book, you might find yourself divided.
The Netflix adaptation, released on November 2, 2023, has spurred a mix of reactions. Initially, the series premiered at the 2023 Toronto International Film Festival where critics were not too kind. Only a third of the nine reviews so far have been positive, as reported by Rotten Tomatoes.
What Critics Are Saying
Critics, especially those who cherished the novel, labeled the changes in the series as superficial and unnecessary, claiming it made the story cliché and monotonous. Comments from Ben Travers of IndieWire and Daniel Fienberg from The Hollywood Reporter reflect on how the adaptation’s plot deviates significantly from the novel, lacking the emotional depth and richness that made the book a hit.
However, the adaptation’s writer, Steven Knight, and director, Shawn Levy, aimed for a more optimistic ending, possibly making the series more appealing to viewers not familiar with the novel or those seeking a lighter watch.
A Look at the Original Novel
The novel, a 2014 war story by American author Anthony Doerr, has been celebrated for its lyrical writing style, short chapters, and detailed sensory descriptions, especially from the perspective of Marie-Laure, a blind French girl. It’s a deeply moving tale, set during World War II, that explores themes of human resilience and the wonders of science and nature amidst chaos.
‘All the Light We Cannot See’ won notable awards, including the Pulitzer Prize for Fiction, and has sold over 15 million copies worldwide. Its success lies in its ability to showcase the harsh realities of war while maintaining a hopeful outlook on life.
Final Verdict
So, is ‘All the Light We Cannot See’ good? If you’re hoping for a faithful adaptation of the novel, you might be disappointed. The series introduces significant changes that have not resonated well with critics. However, if you’re new to the story or are willing to view it with fresh eyes, you might find the series a worthwhile watch, especially with its attempt to end on a hopeful note.
Ultimately, whether the series is ‘good’ is subjective and will vary greatly depending on individual tastes and expectations.